*Corresponding Author:
P. V. Swamy
Department of Pharmaceutics, Shri Vishnu College of Pharmacy, Vishnupur, Bhimavaram-534 202, India
E-mail: [email protected]
K. V. R. Murthy
A.U. College of Pharmaceutical Sciences, Andhra University, Visakhapatnam-530 003, India
Date of Submission 24 January 2019
Date of Revision 21 June 2019
Date of Acceptance 24 September 2019
Indian J Pharm Sci 2019;81(6):1036-1044  

This is an open access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-ShareAlike 3.0 License, which allows others to remix, tweak, and build upon the work non-commercially, as long as the author is credited and the new creations are licensed under the identical terms


In the era of increased prevalence of bacterial resistance and outbreak of resistant infectious diseases, it is essential to develop effective therapeutic strategies towards multi-drug resistant pathogens. In this scenario, silver nanoparticles were tailored using Annona squamosa leaf extract and evaluated using various characterization techniques such as high-performance thin-layer chromatography, UV/Vis, scanning electron microscopy, X-ray powder diffraction, and Fourier-transform infrared spectroscopy. The synthesized AgNPs were assessed for antibacterial activity towards various Gram-positive and Gram-negative bacteria. In addition, the pharmacodynamic interaction of green synthesized AgNPs was assessed with gentamicin towards various bacteria as a novel adjuvant protocol, which revealed the remarkable antibacterial effect in comparison with AgNPs, or gentamicin alone. The superior biological activity was attributed to metabolites in plant extract, synthetic strategy of ultra-small AgNPs and synergistic effect of nano antibiotics.


Multi-drug resistance, silver nanoparticles, gentamicin, antibacterial activity, synergy

Nanotechnology attains considerable attention in pharmaceutical world to open new pathways that are capable of overcoming resistance mechanisms of bacteria[1]. Hospital acquired infections has become a cosmopolitan problem with reported resistance to all known classes of antibiotics[2]. Many adjuvant therapies have developed by the physicians and researchers to deal with multi-drug resistant bacteria but hampered due to exhibition of broad-spectrum action, drug-drug interactions, extended resistance mechanisms and incompatible pharmacodynamic and pharmacokinetic profiles[3]. In pharmaceutical research, nano-scaled structures endeavor various theragnostic applications in a cost effective approach in terms of drug discovery, designing and delivery techniques[4,5]. Metals are known to be antibacterial since ancient times before any conventional antibiotics discovered. Nanotechnology employs metals as inorganic nanoparticles (NPs) that show their pleiotropic effect in targeting bacterial cellular process. Metallic NPs exhibit absolutely novel characteristics in comparison with bulk metals in terms of antibacterial, antioxidant, anticancer properties with less toxicity[6-8]. Synthesizing NPs through physical and chemical methods are capital and labor intensive with the involvement of non-polar solvents and toxic chemicals (capping and reducing agents) that are likely to induce toxicity issues[9,10]. Therefore, in recent times, an ecofriendly and bio-compatible method emerged with involvement of microorganisms and plants as environmentally sociable reducing and capping agents to reduce toxicity issues[11,12]. Though microbial-based synthesis have proven to be the potential bio-factories in nanoparticle synthesis, due to the complexity in isolating and culturing of microbes, plants and plant parts play a vital role in biological synthesis[13,14]. Phytosynthesis of NPs offers rapid, stable and easily scalable process in a cost effective way due to the presence of a wide range of metabolites. Therefore, phytosynthetic inorganic NPs encompass metals in nano form with incorporation of plant metabolites to provide effective antibacterial action in a safer approach[15]. Though inorganic NPs show excellent antibacterial action, with vast research under consideration, researchers cannot ignore antibiotics that have contributed to a better quality of life. Thus, combinational approach of green inorganic NPs with antibiotics can be an assurance for non-toxic and more effective bactericidal action as bacteria cannot develop instant mechanisms to attain resistance to the multi-mode mechanistic antibacterial approach[16-19]. In present study, silver (Ag) NPs are prepared and investigated as silver have shown its proficiency in dealings with biological systems and biomedical applications[13,15]. Annona squamosa leaves are preferred for the reduction process in synthesizing NPs, as they possess interesting medicinal properties along with treatment of wound and urinary tract infections[20]. In addition to bactericidal action of Ag and A. squamosa metabolites, gentamicin is elected in this adjuvant therapy as it holds unique properties in bactericidal action by inhibiting bacterial protein synthesis[21]. As gentamicin attain resistance to many Gram-negative and Gram-positive strains, this adjuvant therapy of gentamicin with A. squamosa-AgNPs was tested on different Gram-positive and negative bacterial strains in comparison with AgNPs and gentamicin alone.

Materials and Methods

A. squamosa leaves were collected from the surroundings of Andhra University, Visakhapatnam, Andhra Pradesh, India, which were authenticated in the Botany department and a voucher specimen was kept in the herbarium (no. 22290). All reagents used in this study were of analytical grade and were procured from Sigma Aldrich, Pune, India. Staphylococcus aureus NCIM 2079, Pseudomonas aeruginosa NCIM 5514, Acinetobacter baumannii NCIM 5654, Proteus vulgaris NCIM 2813 were purchased from the National Collection of Industrial Microorganisms (NCIM), NCL, Pune, India. Enterococcus faecium MTCC5153 was obtained from the Microbial type culture collection, Chandigarh, India. Agar medium and gentamicin was procured from HiMedia, Mumbai, India.

Preparation of A. squamosa leaf extract:

Fresh A. squamosa leaves were employed to extract the active constituents. The leaves were thoroughly rinsed with tap water and then with double-distilled water to get rid of dust particles. The leaves were dried in shade and made into a coarse powder. A. squamosa leaf powder (5 g) was mixed with 100 ml of distilled water and subjected to boiling at 60° in a water bath for 10 min. The mixture was cooled and filtered through a muslin cloth followed by Whatman no. 1 filter paper. Later, the filtrate was centrifuged at 10 000 rpm for 10 min. The supernatant was collected and autoclaved for 15 min at 121° under 15 lbs pressure. A clear solution with greenish yellow color was collected and stored in screw-capped bottles at 4-8° and used as a reducing agent in AgNP synthesis.

Phytosynthesis of AgNPs:

To synthesize AgNPs, the conditions were optimized by fixing 2 of the components among Ag salt concentration, time and plant extract and by altering one component in each experiment. The optimized condition was predicted through the color change and also confirmed by periodic monitoring of UV/Vis spectra. AgNO3 (≥99.5 % purity) solution and aqueous extract of appropriate concentrations were prepared using double-distilled water. The reduction of Ag ions from AgNO3 to Ag was detected through a color change of the solution due to the reducing capability of metabolites in the extract. The nanoparticle dispersion was subjected to centrifugation at 10 000 rpm at 4° for 15 min. The obtained pellets were re-dispersed in methanol and re-centrifuged. The pellet was again washed with deionized water to remove any unbound extract or impurities. The obtained NPs were dried at 80° in a hot air oven. The obtained powder concentrate of Ag NPs was stored at 4° in air tight containers for further characterization, and antibacterial studies.

Characterization of AgNPs:

The chromatographic fingerprint profile of A. squamosa leaf extract was studied using high-performance thinlayer chromatography (HPTLC) analysis Camag Linomat 5, Linomat5_211497 instrument programmed with WIN CATS software to investigate the phytochemical profile. The synthesized AgNPs were characterized by UV/Vis (Shimadzu UV/VIS 2450) in the wavelength range of 300-700 nm to measure the biophysical properties. scanning electron microscope (SEM)–EDX (Jeol JSM-6610-LV- with Oxford EDS) analysis was performed at an accelerated voltage of 200 kV to elucidate morphology, structure and composition. The X-ray diffraction (PANalytical: XPERT-PRO) was operated at 40 kv and 30 mA under Cu Kα radiations (λ=1.54060˚A) using nickel monochromator at a range of 2ɵ from 10° to 80° to examine the crystalline nature of synthesized AgNPs. Fourier-transform infrared spectroscopy (FTIR, Shimadzu FT-IR 21) analysis of A. squamosa leaf extract and A. squamosa-AgNPs was evaluated using KBR pellet in a wavelength range of 4000 to 400 cm-1 at a resolution of 4 cm−1 to detect the possible functional groups (biomolecules) responsible for AgNPs formation.

Antibacterial adjuvant assay:

Antibacterial adjuvant was tested on 5 bacterial strains namely, S. aureus, A. baumannii, P. aeruginosa, E. faecium and P. vulgaris. The bacterial strains were placed on sterile Mueller Hinton agar slants at 4°. Each bacterial strain was placed in 50 ml of sterile nutrient broth in a 100 ml conical flask and incubated for 24 h to activate the bacterial strains. The bacterial inoculums were standardized with respect to McFarland standard no. 0.5 with 1.5×108 CFU/ml bacterial density. The bacterial susceptibility with A. squamosa-AgNPs, gentamicin, and A. squamosa-AgNPs in combination with gentamicin was tested on bacterial strains by agar well diffusion method.

Twenty five milliliters of ml of MHA was mixed with 500 μl of test cultures, poured in the petri plate and left for solidification. Four wells of 6 mm each were made in each plate with the help of sterile cork borer. The minimum inhibitory concentration (MIC) of A. squamosa-AgNPs was estimated using two-fold serial dilutions with in a concentration range of 3.125 to 50 μg/ml. The wells were loaded with 100 μl of AgNPs (25 μg/ml), 100 μl gentamicin (50 μg/ml), and combination of gentamicin with A. squamosa-AgNPs each at a quantity of 50 μl in dimethyl sulfoxide (DMSO; 37.5 μg/ml) and incubated for 24 h at 37° using DMSO as control. The zone of inhibition (ZOI) was measured (in mm) by repeating the experimentation thrice and the % of area increase with adjuvancy was calculated using the formula[19], ZOI of (AgNPs+antibiotic)2–ZOI of antibiotic2/ZOI of antibiotic2×100.

Statistical analysis:

The one-way analysis of variance (ANOVA) method was used the ZOI of each nanoparticle or gentamicin against each bacteria used. In order to establish the statistical significance, the values were assessed by using GraphPad Prism version 5.03 (GraphPad Software, Inc. CA, USA trail version). All the experiments were done in triplicate and the results as expressed as mean±SD, n=3, and the statistical significance was accepted at a level of p<0.05 for all the combinational effect of metallic NPs with gentamicin, where null hypothesis was rejected and alternate hypothesis was accepted. Hence, there was a significant difference between the individual nanoparticle/gentamicin antibacterial activity and in the combinational antibacterial activity. Hence, combinational therapy with NPs is more effective than the individual treatment with gentamicin.

Results and Discussion

Preliminary screening was performed to detect the presence of numerous phytochemicals present in A. squamosa leaf extract using reagent tests. The phytochemical screening revealed the presence of various primary and secondary metabolites with significant biological value. HPTLC is an updated qualitative analytic tool for identification of biomolecules in the sample with the display of more resolved spots and effective analysis of compounds. In the current study, the HPTLC profile of A. squamosa leaf extract was carried out with petroleum ether and chloroform solvents separately using definite solvent ratios and analyzed before and after spray treatment (methanol:sulphuric acid) under UV wavelength, 254 and 366 nm, respectively. The HPTLC analysis reveals the diverse phytochemicals present in A. squamosa leaf extract, which might be a valuable source for the effective synthesis of AgNPs and enhancement in biological activity. In addition, A. squamosa leaf extract reported to have numerous phytochemicals such as alkaloids, flavonoids, phenols, proteins, carbohydrates, glycosides, saponins, tannins and the same was confirmed in this study by phytochemical analysis[22-24]. Among which, ferric chloride test detected the presence of phenols by developing bluish green instantly after addition of ferric chloride reagent and lead acetate test proved the presence of phenolic compounds by forming bulky white precipitate, which confirmed abundant presence of phenols. Moreover, phenols have high potential to act as reducing and capping agent in the preparation of stable NPs as evident from recent reports[25,26]. Thus, phenols present in A. squamosa leaf extract might play a vital role for the formation of AgNPs.

The AgNPs formation was detected through color change from colorless silver nitrate to dark yellow color and then finally to colloidal brown color within few hours after mixing the leaf extracts solution (figure 1). The color change of the medium could be due to the excitation of surface plasmon vibrations[27]. In order to obtain stable and uniform AgNPs formation, the various physicochemical conditions were optimized such as concentration of precursor solution and leaf extract and reaction time as these factors can significantly influence the size, shape, and morphology[13]. The optimization process of Ag nanoparticle synthesis was examined analytically via UV/Vis spectroscopy as shown in figure 2. In aqueous solution, AgNPs exhibit strong surface plasmon resonance around 430 nm for the formation of well-stabilized AgNPs[28]. Based on the earlier reported parameters for optimization of NPs, the UV/Vis peak with high intensity and low bandwidth were considered for the optimization of NPs[13,27,29,30].


Figure 1: Color change variations of the A. squamosa-AgNP solutions with different optimization conditions


Figure 2: Absorption spectra of AgNPs obtained from various optimizing parameters

For optimizing condition for AgNPs, temperature of reaction and pH are not under the focus of study, as the preparation of AgNPs was aimed not to employ any external energy or agents. High temperature synthesis readily form NPs but with large size[31]. Moreover, at high temperatures biological moieties from the extract may be lost which may rise agglomeration. Thus, the present investigation aimed at controlled green synthesis at room temperature to synthesize small size stable AgNPs. pH can be maintained at the range of 4-6 in case of green synthesis[32]. Initially, the effect of the silver nitrate precursor solution on the formation of AgNPs was studied systematically by changing the molar concentration of silver nitrate in 10 ml by fixing the volume of extract as 3 ml and 1 h as the reaction time. No absorption spectrum was observed for 0.002 M concentration of silver nitrate (figure 2a). With increase in metal precursor concentration (0.005 M), the absorption band was observed around 430 nm. At 0.01 M concentration, optimum intensity peak with lower band width was noticed. The enhancement in bandwidth was detected with increase in the metal precursor concentration (0.01 to 0.05 M). From the earlier reports, enhanced band width infers large sized NPs/agglomeration. Therefore, the metal precursor concentration was optimized as 0.01 M, as the lower absorption bandwidth reflects the formation of uniformly small sized AgNPs[13,29,30]. Reaction time is a crucial factor to obtain the mono dispersed small NPs. By fixing the metal precursor concentration (0.01 M) and volume of leaf extract (3 ml), reaction time was monitored by UV/Vis spectra. With an increase in reaction time, the absorbance intensity was increased with reduced absorption width simultaneously until 2 h. On further increase in reaction time from 2 to 8 h, enlarged width of absorption spectra was seen[13,29,30] (figure 2b), indicating enhancement of particle size and/or agglomeration and hence reaction time was optimized as 2 h. Further optimization was focused on A. squamosa leaf extract volume, by fixing metal precursor concentration (0.01 M) and reaction time 2 h. On rise of A. squamosa leaf extract volume to 5 ml, absorption band width was reduced with increased intensity was observed, which indicated small sized NPs with high yield[13,27,29,30]. By further increasing the volume to 10 ml, the absorption band width was increased (figure 2c), representing larger size of AgNPs and/or agglomeration of particles as confirmed from previous reports[13,27,29,30]. Therefore, 5 ml was considered as the desired volume for preparation of NPs without agglomeration.

To examine the size, surface morphology and crystalline nature of the synthesized A. squamosa-AgNPs, XRD, and SEM analysis was performed. The SEM image exhibited larger clusters with numerous small particles, which might be due to the evaporation of solvent during SEM sample preparation (figure 3a). The energydispersive X-ray (EDX) spectra of A. squamosa-AgNPs were examined at an accelerating voltage (15 kv), which displayed 91.36 % yield (weight %) of elemental Ag in L line (figure 3b). The XRD pattern of A. squamosa leaf extract mediated synthesis of AgNPs has been evaluated in the range of 20-90° and high-intensity peaks of A. squamosa-AgNPs were detected at 38, 44, 64, 78 and 81° that corresponds to Bragg reflections (111), (200), (211), (311), and (222), respectively (figure 4a). These peaks represent the exact peak positions of the silver face center cubic lattice structure. There are no additional reflections observed indicating absence of impurities or amorphous organic phase. From the XRD pattern, the average crystallite size was calculated by the Debye-Scherer Eqn. and Williamson-Hall plot and was approximately 9 and 6.6 nm, respectively.


Figure 3: (a) SEM and (b) EDS analysis of green synthesized A. squamosa-AgNPs


Figure 4: (a) XRD Pattern (b) FTIR spectra of green synt hesized A. squamosa-AgNPs

FTIR analysis was employed to identify the bio-molecules that are responsible for silver ion reduction and capping of AgNPs, which leads to efficient stabilization for the biosynthetic process of AgNPs. The FTIR spectra of A. squamosa leaf extract and A. squamosa-AgNPs were depicted in figure 4b and Table 1. The FTIR spectra of A. squamosa leaf extract have dominant absorption bands at 3348, 2903, 2349, 1441, 1251, 1050 and 663 cm−1. These absorption bands were assigned to O-H, C-H stretching, C-C stretching vibrations, O-H bend/amide, C-N stretching, C-OH vibrations and N-H (amines) respectively[33-35]. The absorption bands with low intensity at 1734 and 1386 cm−1 denote C-O stretching vibrations (carboxylic acid)[36].

Functional Group Characteristic absorption band (cm–1) Absorption bands in AS leaf extract (cm–1) Absorption bands in AgNPs (cm–1)
Water OH Stretch 3700-3100 3348 3469
Alcohol OH stretch 3600-3200
Carboxylic acid OH stretch 3600-2500
N-H stretch 3500-3350
-C-H aldehyde 2900-2800 2903 2899
-C-H stretch 2950-2840
C≡C- stretch 2260-2100 2349
C=O amide 1700-1500 1514,1608 1553,1639
O-H bend, amide III 1480-1315 1441 1410
–CO groups 1050-1150 1050 1046

Table 1: FTIR Spectra of A. squamosa Leaf Extract and AGNP

The FTIR spectra of AgNPs exhibited bands around 1100, 1400, 1636, 2132 and 3300 cm−1. The most prominent band at 1410 cm−1 attributed to COO stretching vibration[13,35]. The strong absorption band around 3348 cm−1 representsed O-H, which corresponded to O-H stretching of alcohol and phenolic compounds or stretching of the –NH band of an amino group. The band at 1640 cm−1 is due to stretching vibration of –CO amide groups in the ketones, aldehydes and carboxylic acids[37]. The bands at 1083 and 1046 cm−1 indicated the presence of –CO groups. The presence of a weak band at 2980 cm−1 is related to aliphatic C-H stretching in methyl and methylene groups[35,37]. The similarity of bands in both the A. squamosa leaf extract and A. squamosa-AgNPs (Table 1), might be due to capped biomolecules on to the surface of AgNPs.

The zeta potential measurement of AgNPs exhibited the surface charges of the particles and exhibited a value of −20 mV (figure 5), suggesting higher stability of AgNPs. The large negative potential value might be attributed to the capping of phenols present in the leaf extract of A. squamosa.


Figure 5: Zeta potential distribution of green synthesized
A. squamosa-AgNPs Zeta potential: –20.5 mV

In the emergent era to find the novel antimicrobials, adjuvant therapy of green synthesized NPs with an antibiotic seems to be a viable option to treat antibioticresistant strains[16-19]. All the bacterial experimentation was done in a laminar air flow chamber under sterile conditions. The antimicrobial activity of A. squamosa-AgNPs (25 μg/ml), gentamicin (50 μg/ml) and gentamicin A. squamosa-AgNPs (50 μl of each sample) were tested against S. aureus, A. baumannii, P. aeruginosa, E. faecium, and P. vulgaris.

There were reports stating that some of these bacterial strains attained considerable resistance to gentamicin[21]. The MIC of A. squamosa-AgNPs in case of S. aureus, A. baumannii, P. aeruginosa, E. faecium, P. vulgaris were 3.125, 3.125, 3.125, 6.25, and 3.125 μg/ml respectively and the ZOI was increased in a dosedependent manner. The green synthesized AgNPs have shown considerable ZOI even at the minimum concentration range towards all the tested bacteria which proves their effective activity as antimicrobial agent. A. squamosa-AgNPs (25 μg/ml) have shown almost equal antibacterial activity to that of gentamicin (50 μg/ml) as shown in figure 6.


Figure 6: Synergetic antibacterial activity of AgNP against wound/burn infection causing bacteria

The mechanism behind the combination of nanoparticle and antibiotic is still unclear but with assumptions such as covalent bonding between the nanoparticle and sulfhydryl groups (–SH) groups in antibiotics or due to hydrophobic interactions or because of electrostatic interactions between positively charged zone in antibiotics and negatively charged particle[20]. The combination of antibiotic with NPs may alter the properties of NPs with enhanced effects as described in a report[38].

In the combination assay of A. squamosa-AgNPs with gentamicin, it has shown significant area increase of 39.68, 62.21, 18, 9.7, 32.47 %, respectively towards S. aureus, A. baumannii, P. aeruginosa, E. faecium, P. vulgaris. The percent increase in area is an evidence of synergistic action, which is attributed from combinational effect of green synthesized AgNPs and the antibiotic as shown in Table 2. It is interesting to note that this combination showed synergistic effect towards all the tested microorganisms without any indifferent or negative activity. On observation, it is clear that this adjuvant technique has shown greater effect on Gram-negative bacteria than Gram-positive bacteria. The difference in activity between the Gram strains might be due to the thin peptidoglycan layer in case of Gram-negative strains, which is readily feasible for penetration of the nanoparticle antibiotic combination[13,16]. However, the % increase in zones of inhibition of Gram-positive bacteria is also significant, which might be due to ultra-small size of synthesized A. squamosa-AgNPs that can penetrate even through thick peptidoglycan layer. The probable mechanism for antibacterial activity by these adjuvant combinations is still under preliminary investigation and possibly due to adherence and penetration in to the bacterial cell wall and interaction with sulphur and phosphorous groups of bacterial DNA ensuing bactericidal action[17-19]. Due to green chemistry approach in nano field, it’s an assurance that bio-synthesized NPs are usually biocompatible than that of chemically synthesized NPs[39-42].

Bacterial strain A. squamosa- AgNPs (25 μg/ml) Gentamicin (50 μg/ml) [A] A. squamosa- AgNPs+ gentamicin [B] % increase in area (B2–A2/A2)×100
Zone of inhibition (ZOI) in mm (mean with standard deviation)
Pseudomanas aeruginosa 15.24±0.12 17.54±0.17 20.73±0.15 39.68
Acinetobacter baumannii 15.8±0.25 18.31±0.15 23.32±0.09 62.21
Staphylococcus aureus 16.25±0.17 20.28±0.23 22.067±0.12 18
Enterococcus faecium 20.42±0.15 22.77±0.21 23.85±0.15 9.7
Proteus vulgaris 19.45±0.22 21.66±0.12 24.93±0.18 32.47

Table 2: Synergetic Activity of A. squamosa-AGNPS and Gentamicin Against Bacterial Pathogens

In conclusion, AgNPs of ultra-small size with crystalline nature were prepared through an ecofriendly process using A. squamosa leaf extract as a reducing agent. In spite of potential antibacterial activity displayed by bio-synthesized AgNPs, with adjuvant combination of green synthesized NPs and conventional antibiotics there was a vast improvement in antibacterial activity in comparison with antibiotics in a resistance free and toxic free manner due to the multimode antibacterial activity, which was well demonstrated with significant fold percent increase in antibacterial activity. With the fascinating green nano chemistry in combination with antibiotics, the resistance challenge can be accepted by the pharmaceutical world. Further studies on evaluation of exact mechanism of A. squamosa-AgNPs for antibacterial activity need to be evaluated in future research.


We acknowledge Shri Vishnu College of Pharmacy for guidance and support in carrying out research and writing this article. We also acknowledge DST-Purse, Andhra University for characterization techniques. Authors thank Prof. S.B. Padaal, Botany Department for authenticating the plant material.

Conflicts of interest:

The authors report no conflicts of interest. The authors alone are responsible for the content and writing of this article.